Before Reading:1. What are some examples of times when people must obey an authority figure, even though they may not want to?
An example of a time when people must obey an authority figure when they wouldn't want to would be in a dictatorship. In a dictatorship, there is one single ruler who controls everything in his/her country and everyone must obey his orders, or they'll receive some form of punishment.
2. Must military commanders enforce harsh discipline on their soldiers?
Yes, military commanders must enforce harsh discipline on their soldier. The reason is because if the soldiers aren't used to harsh discipline when there's not a war, they won't obey when there actually is a war. Also, if they are disciplined, soldiers will work more efficiently and thus, reduce casualties.
3. Is it important for a military outfit to work as a team?
Yes, teamwork in key for war. If you have no teamwork, everyone will be off someplace doing their own thing and everything would just be chaos.
4. What are the consequences if a commander is unable to keep his or her troops under control during wartime?
If a commander is unable to keep his or her troops under control, there would be a huge mess. There would be a lot more casualties if everyone was doing different things.
Read and Analyze Poem:In "The Charge of the Light Brigade" 600 courageous men charged into battle knowing they stood little chance. Tennyson uses the phrases "Valley of Death", "Mouth of Hell", and "Jaws of Death" to show that there was no way out for the Light Brigade once they had started charging. It also emphasizes the desperateness of the soldiers as they rush into their enemies hands.
Tennyson also repeats "600" in his poem. He first says "Rode the six hundred" to emphasize that 600 men were rushing into the battle. Then he says "Then they rode back, but not the six hundred." This shows that though they retreated, not all of the 600 were there, meaning they had died.
Also, in the second stanza it says "Was there a man dismay'd? Not tho' the soldier knew Someone had blunder'd." Though it clearly doesn't say who had fallen, it probably means the commander, Lord Raglan. He had failed to control and enforce discipline on his soldiers, resulting in a great misunderstanding. Though the Light Brigade may be courageous for charging into a battle full of passion and strength, they had failed to follow their leader's instructions, which led to a disaster.